Well folks, it’s been a while since our last Would You Rather? You know how the game works, choose either option #1 or option #2, and live with the consequences.  Today, we have a battle of creamy white substances that purport to both be dairy.  One of them you can continue to eat at your leisure for the rest of your life, the other you must give up, and can never, ever, ever eat again in any form.

So which do you keep, and which do you give up? Today’s battle is…Cream Cheese vs. Sour Cream!

Option #1: Keep the Cream Cheese!


Option #2: Keep the Sour Cream!


Things to consider: bagels, philly sushi rolls, cheesecake, frosting, dips, nachos, tacos, burritos, baked potatoes.

[poll id=”72″]

10 Responses

  1. Cassie

    Greek Yogurt plain tastes just like sour cream but better for you, forgo the sour cream, keep the cream cheese!

  2. Lis

    Cream cheese is amazing.

    Sour cream, don’t let the door hit you on your way out… and take cottage cheese with you.

  3. antonio

    lets be real bagel and cream cheese enuff said. You couldnt have cheese cake. Or dorritos or hot flamming cheetos with cream cheese.

    If you havent tried them you need to. Delish

  4. Julie

    This was the meanest ever.

    These are my two favorite foods! I eat each of them at least once a day. Sigh.. I’d have to keep the cream cheese.

  5. lynnnj

    Impossible choice. I went with cream cheese – because of the bagels. But my cheesecake recipe has both cream cheese and sour cream. Thanks, Cassie, for reminding me that Greek yogurt can generally stand in for sour cream.

  6. Cher

    I had to choose cream cheese. I love cheesecake and its in a lot more recipes that I like. Also sour cream is easier to substitute.

  7. Zeina

    Cream cheese is too good with peanut butter and baggels and cheese cake I can live with out sour cream on a taco lol il use cream cheese instead lol

  8. Mark

    While I can’t justify ridding the world of either, I simply can’t live without sour cream. Baked potato with cream cheese? I think not!


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.