Time for a new Would You Rather. Today’s question pits two classic picnic or BBQ side dishes against one another. One of them you must give up for life, but the other you can continue eating to your hearts content. Which side dish will remain a part of your life?

Option #1: You can never eat coleslaw again.

Option #2: You can never eat potato salad again.

Pictures via Nancy’s Recipes and Eating Vine.

Well So Good readers, which side dish do you keep in your life and why?

[poll id=”148″]

9 Responses

  1. DAVE ID

    That’s a tough choice. I love both almost equally.

    You guys should had a feature to comments so that commenters be updated on new comments.

  2. Spam

    Besides the fact that I love potatoes a ton more than cabbage…there are so many different ways you can make potato salad, while cole slaw is pretty much the same thing all the time.

    Potato salad it is, for me.

  3. Marisa

    I don’t care for either like some of the commentators above (don’t like mayo), but I’ll give up coleslaw to keep German potato salad.

  4. Anonymous Kitteh

    Since almost every coleslaw I’ve ever had tasted a lot like Satan’s arse, I’d have to go with giving up coleslaw.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.