Voting on this match-up is now closed. Mr. Pibb (66%) crushes Mtn Dew Pitch Black (34%).

Mr. Pibb lives on, but only kind of, as Pibb Xtra, which “Pibbheads” (I may or may not have just made that word up) claim is a noticeably different taste/formula from the original. Mountain Dew Pitch Black was a limited edition release that apparently did not catch on enough to warrant full time production. Which would you bring back?

Pibb vs PB

(Click to enlarge and see full bracket)

Discontinued Foods Bracket

One Response

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.