Discontinued Foods Bracket: Mr. Pibb vs. Mtn Dew Pitch Black

Voting on this match-up is now closed. Mr. Pibb (66%) crushes Mtn Dew Pitch Black (34%).

Mr. Pibb lives on, but only kind of, as Pibb Xtra, which “Pibbheads” (I may or may not have just made that word up) claim is a noticeably different taste/formula from the original. Mountain Dew Pitch Black was a limited edition release that apparently did not catch on enough to warrant full time production. Which would you bring back?

(Click to enlarge and see full bracket)