Voting on these match-ups is now closed. Milky Way (86%) crushes Warheads (14%), Sweet Tarts (68%) beat out Bit-O-Honey (32%), Jolly Rancher (51%) sneaks by Tootsie Roll Pops (49%) and Twix (89%) destroy Smarties (11%).

1st round Candy Madness voting continues! Voting on these match-ups goes from 2 pm today to 2 pm Friday. If you aren’t hip yet to Candy Madness, read our intro post here, fill out your bracket with friends, and join us each day to vote on new match-ups.

Here are the next four first round match-ups of our tournament:

 Who are you voting for and why? Which of these contenders do you think can run the bracket and make the final four? Any potential upsets? Share your thoughts in the comments after you vote.

[poll id=”313″]

[poll id=”314″]

[poll id=”315″]

[poll id=”316″]

7 Responses

  1. Mark

    Wow Twix is 100% winner so far, craziness. I didn’t even know Bit O honey was made anymore. I loved those as a kid and would make out like a king on Halloween because everyone would trade me for them.

    Reply
  2. Smile

    Just reading “Warheads” made my tongue curl with a “can still taste the sour” feeling. Don’t get me wrong; I love them! But to pick them over Milky Way? Yeah, not going to happen.

    I can easily take down a bag of Sweet Tarts! Voted Tootsie because it’s a 2-in-1 aswesomeness, but I don’t mind if either they or Jolly Rancher move on.

    I also like Smarties, despite them being a little chalky (though nowhere near as bad as Necco Wafers or those valentine hearts). But again, over a Twix? Nope.

    Best way to eat a Twix: take off the top chocolate/caramel part (normally comes off in one easy strip), bite off all the chocolate from the cookie on both sides and ends, eat said naked cookie, enjoy chocolate/caramel part. (:

    Reply
  3. Cynthia

    So far 3 of the 4 are going my way. Sad that Smarties are losing to Twix, although not really surprised. They are pretty tasty.

    Reply
  5. JenInChicago

    I agree with Smile on how to eat a Twix….I save the cookie for last.

    I am flabbergasted that Tootsie Roll Pops and Jolly Rancher are neck and neck…..Tootsie Roll Pops cannot compare!

    Reply
  6. SueWinkle

    American Smarties appear to be a version of Canadian Rockets (or so it looks like), if it had been the Canadian Smarties vs Twix, I think they would have won! Enjoying the voting.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.